Protein: How did we get so Obsessed? 🥩
Protein is having…let’s call it…a moment.
Walk into a supermarket and you'll find protein yoghurts, protein puddings, protein cereals, protein bars, protein coffees, protein shakes, protein oats - even protein water. It seems that every and any food product has the word PROTEIN slapped across the front of it. Even foods we typically know to be a natural source of protein, like nuts or cheese now have to remind us that they too are sources of this holy grail nutrient.
On social media, the conversation is just as loud. We're told to ‘hit our protein target’, prioritise protein at every meal, add protein to our snacks and make sure we're getting enough after exercise.
Protein is an important nutrient. But the amount of attention it receives now, is about more than its role in the body. Protein has become part of the language of health, fitness and self-improvement.
So how did we get here?
First things first: what actually is protein? 🧬
Protein is one of the three macronutrients, alongside carbohydrate and fat. It is made up of amino acids, which the body uses for a huge range of functions, for examples to:
🦴 build and maintain tissues, including muscle and bone
🩹 repair tissues
🧪 make enzymes and hormones
🛡️ support the immune system
🚚 transport substances around the body
⚙️ carry out countless processes that keep the body functioning
There are different types of amino acids - some the body can make itself (non-essential) and others we have to get from our diets (essential).
So, yes, protein matters.
But ‘protein is important’ is a very different statement from ‘you should be trying to maximise your protein intake at all times’. And this is a distinction that is often overlooked.
From nutrient to fitness obsession 🏋️♀️
Protein has become particularly prominent alongside the rise of the fitness industry and social media fitness culture.
Muscle-building content, gym culture, bodybuilding, sports nutrition and the growth of the wellness industry have all helped turn protein into something we are encouraged to actively monitor.
Protein is now associated with:
💪 building muscle
🏃♀️ exercise and recovery
⚡ performance
🔬 “science-backed” nutrition
🎯 optimisation
🔥 changing the way your body looks
And this has changed the way we talk about ordinary food. A typical breakfast of eggs on toast or granola and Greek yoghurt has suddenly become a ‘protein-packed start to the day’, a jacket potato with beans is a satiating high-protein lunch, and we’re adding cottage cheese to literally everything to boost its protein content.
The fitness industry has helped turn protein from one component of our diets into something that can feel like a measure of whether we're eating well.
When protein becomes part of restriction 🚩
There is nothing inherently problematic about wanting to include protein in your diet. Someone might increase their protein intake because they're strength training, recovering from illness or injury, or simply because they enjoy protein-rich foods.
But for someone vulnerable to disordered eating, the current protein obsession can provide a very convincing new set of rules.
Sometimes the focus on protein isn't really about getting enough protein. It can become a way of:
🚫 avoiding carbohydrate or fat-containing foods
📉 trying to reduce overall food intake
🔢 creating another number to hit
🥣 choosing foods according to their protein content rather than preference
🧠 justifying restriction as ‘healthy eating’
Protein is also frequently promoted as being particularly filling or ‘satiating’. In an eating disorder context, advice about choosing foods that will ‘keep you fuller for longer’ can sometimes be used to reduce how much or how often someone eats. The reality is, all food groups play a role in signalling satiety and fullness.
Similarly, ‘prioritising protein’ can provide a socially acceptable explanation for avoiding foods that someone is frightened of.
“I'm not avoiding bread - I'm prioritising protein.”
“I'm not scared of full fat yoghurts - I’m prioritising protein”
“I prefer protein pancakes because they’re more filling”
So how much do we actually need? 🤔
There isn't one protein requirement that applies to everyone.
Needs vary according to things such as:
👶 age and stage of growth
🏃♀️ activity and training
🤰 pregnancy and breastfeeding
🩺 illness
🩹 injury and recovery
👴 ageing
🍽️ overall dietary intake
There are certainly circumstances where protein requirements are higher. But this doesn't mean that everyone needs to be deliberately increasing their protein intake.
In the UK, most people's diets already provide plenty of protein. Protein is found across a huge range of everyday foods, including:
🥛 milk and yoghurt
🧀 cheese
🥚 eggs
🍗 meat and poultry
🐟 fish
🫘 beans, peas and lentils
🌱 soya and other plant-based foods
🥜 nuts and seeds
🍞 bread and other cereal foods
You don't need to build your entire diet around protein for your body to be getting enough of it.
We're already eating protein without trying very hard
This is one of the things that gets lost in the current conversation. A typical Western diet naturally contains a lot of protein-containing foods.
Think about an ordinary day:
Breakfast: Porridge with milk, fruit & nut butter 🥣
AM Snack: Coffee with milk & oat biscuits 🍪
Lunch: Grain bowl with chickpeas & hummus or Chicken & avo sandwich 🥪
PM Snack: Granola bar 🥜
Dinner: Spaghetti bolognese with cheese 🍝
Dessert: Yoghurt bowl with cereal 🥛
This is likely to comfortably meet the reference intake for protein for the average person. None of those foods need to be marketed as ‘protein foods’ for them to actually contribute protein to your diet.
But isn't protein good for you? 🧐
Yes.
And this is exactly why protein makes such an effective marketing tool.
‘Protein’ already has positive associations. We know it has important functions in the body, so putting the word prominently on a packet can make a product sound automatically more nutritious.
One 2024 study demonstrated this. Researchers showed 1,022 adults either Special K Original or Special K Protein cereal and asked them how they perceived the products.
The protein-labelled cereal was perceived as:
🥣 healthier
🧬 more nutritious
💪 more beneficial for building muscle
🦴 more beneficial for things such as bone strength
❤️ more beneficial for staying healthy
The presence of the protein claim changed how people perceived the food. The word protein had effectively become a shortcut for healthy. In reality other than having a slightly high protein content - this other assumptions and associations aren’t true.
The protein price tag 💷
There's another side to the protein boom: you can now pay extra for it.
Compare the ordinary version of a food with its protein-branded equivalent and you will often find that the difference isn't as dramatic as the packaging suggests.
The protein version may genuinely contain more protein. But sometimes the difference is relatively modest, while the price difference is considerably more noticeable.
Protein has become something we can sell at a premium - companies know that consumers are incorrectly labelling high protein foods as automatically ‘healthier’ and they know that as a result consumers will pay more for products labelled in this way. They’ve seen an opportunity to make more money and have run with it.
When ‘protein’ says more than it actually tells you 🏷️
There's also an interesting issue with food labelling.
There are rules around nutrition claims such as “source of protein” and “high protein”. These terms have specific criteria that a product has to meet.
But look at how many products now simply make the word PROTEIN the biggest thing on the front of the packet. To get around this criteria, they simply stick the word protein on the packet - although nutritionally this means nothing more than ‘this product contains some protein’.
What consumers see is something very different - the emphasis on the word protein, the space it takes up on the packet and the size of the word, gives the impression that the product being marketed must be actually quite high in protein. Right?! Right?!?!
Wrong
And this isn't actually new...
The idea of protein as something that makes us stronger, healthier and physically better predates protein shakes and Instagram by a very long way.
Research into protein-enhanced foods in Britain in the early twentieth century found that companies were already using advertising to associate protein with (O'Hagan, 2021):
💪 strength
🧍♂️ physical development
🔬 scientific progress
❤️ health
🥩 nourishment
Products such as Plasmon and Emprote were marketed using ideas that feel surprisingly familiar today.
The packaging has changed. The language has changed. The products have changed.
But the basic marketing message hasn't changed quite as much as we might think:
Protein = strength = health = improvement.
And that brings us back to the modern protein boom.
The history of protein marketing shows that this association between protein, strength and health has been deliberately cultivated for well over a century.
Perhaps our current obsession isn't quite as new as it looks.
So where does that leave us? 🌱
I'm not interested in telling you to stop eating protein products.
If you like protein yoghurt, buy the protein yoghurt.
If a protein bar is convenient on a long day, have the protein bar.
If you're training and deliberately including more protein makes sense for you, that's fine too.
The issue is what happens when protein stops being one part of your diet and becomes a measure of whether you've eaten ‘well’. Or your focus on protein is actually covering up a fear of other food groups?
You don't need to:
🥣 add protein to every breakfast
🍫 buy the protein version of every snack
🔢 constantly calculate whether you've had enough
🚫 avoid carbohydrate or fat because they aren't as protein-rich
💷 spend more money on a product simply because “protein” is written across the packet
Protein is simply a nutrient. Every food group has a role to serve in the body - every nutrient has a place and is important. Protein is not the holy grail of nutrients. Eating more and more of it isn't going to save you or dramatically improve your overall health status. Yes, eat enough of it, but also eat enough of everything else your body needs.
References
O’Hagan, L.A. (2021) “Flesh-formers or fads? Historicising the contemporary protein-enhanced food trend,” Food, Culture & Society: An International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, 25(5), pp. pp. 875–898.
McKeon, G.P. and Hallman, W.K. (2024) “Front-of-Package Protein Labels on Cereal Create Health Halos,” Foods (Basel, Switzerland). Switzerland.
_edited.png)




Comments